RECRUITING AGENCIES

7 Best Recruiting Agencies in NYC for Startups (November 2026)

7 MIN READ

SHARE THIS ARTICLE


7 Best Recruiting Agencies in NYC for Startups (November 2026)
SUMMARY

7 NYC recruiting agencies for startups, checked Nov 7, 2026: who each one hires for, how they charge, and one honest downside per firm.

The best recruiting agency in NYC depends on the role you're filling, not on who tops a ranking. Best for New York engineering hires: Averity. Best contingency firm for seed to Series D tech roles: Recruiting from Scratch. Best for sales and go-to-market: Betts Recruiting. Best for VP and C-level tech leaders: Riviera Partners. Best for media, consumer and growth leaders: AC Lion. Best if you'd rather pay by the hour: Dover. Best for skipping the agency fee model entirely: Clera (we built it, more below). Every fact in this post was checked on each firm's own site on November 7, 2026.

Summary table

AgencyBest forKey stat (Nov 7, 2026)One limitation
AverityNYC engineering, data and DevOps hiresTeams split by specialty, office at 365 5th AveNo stage focus or pricing on its site
Recruiting from ScratchContingency tech hiring, seed to Series D300+ placed, 29 days average to hireFee percentage not published
Betts RecruitingSales, CS and revenue rolesPhysical NYC office, five search modelsNo engineering hiring
Riviera PartnersVP and C-level tech leaders1,800+ clients, NYC officeRetained search, priced for senior roles
AC LionMedia, adtech and growth leaders"Since 1997", 1,000+ companies builtNarrow industry focus
DoverPaying for recruiter time, not a percentage$4.8k average cost per hireNot an NYC firm
CleraWarm intros to candidates who want startups2,400+ NYC startups, 1,400+ NYC rolesNo retained or executive search

How we picked

We started from the pages ranking on Google for "best recruiting agencies nyc" and pulled every firm that showed up more than once, about 15 in total. Then we read each firm's own website. A firm made the list if it showed a New York office or a clear New York focus, said which roles it fills, and had at least one checkable number or pricing detail. Hunt Club and Rocket were dropped because neither showed a New York office or concrete numbers on the pages we checked.

Most top results are lists written by recruiting firms that rank themselves first, so we cite them only for fee ranges and say so. We built Clera, so it gets the same fields and one blunt downside as everyone else, and it isn't ranked first.

1. Averity

Best for: startups hiring software, data or DevOps engineers in New York.

Averity is a New York tech recruiting firm with an office at 365 5th Ave. Its site splits the team by specialty: software engineering (full stack and back end), data science and data engineering, and DevOps and security engineering. It describes its focus as "the New York City market".

Why it made the list: recruiters who work one engineering niche in one city know the local pay bands.

Downside: its site lists no stage focus, no client numbers and no pricing. Dover's NYC recruiter guide puts its fees at "the classic 20-25% of first-year salary", but that's a competitor's claim, so confirm it on your first call.

Pricing: not published.

2. Recruiting from Scratch

Best for: seed to Series D startups that want a contingency firm for technical roles.

Recruiting from Scratch lists a New York address at 169 Madison Ave and works with high-growth and AI-native startups. Its homepage says 300+ people placed, 29 days on average from kickoff to signed offer, a first shortlist within 1 to 2 weeks, and 150+ companies, including Scale AI, Coda and Decagon.

Why it made the list: it is one of the few firms here that publishes a time-to-hire number, and you only pay when someone starts.

Downside: the fee percentage isn't on the site, and its /pricing page returns a 404. It also publishes many of the NYC rankings you'll find on Google, including ones that feature itself.

Pricing: contingency, "a percentage of the candidate's first-year salary. No retainers, no upfront fees."

3. Betts Recruiting

Best for: startups building a sales, customer success or revenue team.

Betts Recruiting recruits only go-to-market roles for tech companies: SDRs and BDRs, account executives, sales engineers, customer success, marketing and revenue operations. Its New York page says it works "from a physical office in the city" and names clients like Airtable, Flexport and Grammarly.

Why it made the list: it offers five ways to work together, from contingency and executive search to "Recruitment as a Service".

Downside: no engineering or product hiring. If your next three hires are engineers, look elsewhere.

Pricing: no rates published.

4. Riviera Partners

Best for: hiring a VP of Engineering, CTO or Head of Product.

Riviera Partners places technical leaders only: engineering, product, AI, data, security and design. It lists offices in San Francisco, Los Angeles, New York City, Bozeman, Providence and London, and says it has worked with 1,800+ clients, with 850+ placements at unicorns and 60% repeat clients. It grew its New York team by acquiring New York search firm Bamboo Talent in 2019.

Why it made the list: a first engineering leader is the hire that shapes every hire after it, and this is all Riviera does.

Downside: it's retained search, which means you pay whether or not the hire happens. Dover's guide estimates the fee at "roughly one-third of first-year cash compensation". Too expensive for an individual contributor role.

Pricing: retained, rates not published.

5. AC Lion

Best for: consumer, media, adtech and e-commerce startups hiring growth and digital leaders.

AC Lion is a New York executive search firm that has worked "since 1997" and says it has helped build 1,000+ companies. Besides executive search, it offers contract and fractional hiring. Clients named on its site include Duolingo, Betterment, Codecademy and Lemonade.

Why it made the list: its client list is heavy on New York consumer brands, the network a consumer startup wants.

Downside: the industry focus is narrow. A deep tech or B2B infrastructure startup won't get much from its network.

Pricing: not published.

6. Dover

Best for: startups that want a recruiter's time without a percentage-of-salary fee.

Dover is a marketplace of independent recruiters, not a New York agency. You pick a recruiter and pay hourly, on a flat retainer, or per hire. Its pricing page, updated October 30, 2026, lists a $4.8k average cost per hire across 1,455 hires from pre-seed to Series E, many of them in New York, and says 600+ companies have hired through it.

Why it made the list: the cost per hire is public, which almost no agency on this list does.

Downside: quality depends on the recruiter you pick, and Dover says the average company speaks with 3.9 recruiters before choosing.

Pricing: hourly, retainer or pay per hire. Its hiring software has a $0 plan and a $199 a month plan.

7. Clera

Best for: startups that want warm intros to candidates who already want to work at a startup.

We built Clera. Candidates join once and tell Clera what they want, and startups bid on the ones that fit. Clera then introduces the candidate to your hiring manager with context on why they fit. The homepage lists 2,400+ startups and 1,400+ roles in New York, 253,073 candidates on the platform and 8 days from signup to first interview.

Why it made the list: every candidate has already said yes to startup life, so you skip the call where you find out they only wanted a big-company offer.

Downside: Clera has no New York office and doesn't run retained or executive searches. You meet people who are already on Clera, so a very niche role may get a short list.

Pricing: companies pay when they hire. Free for candidates.

What's changing in NYC agency hiring

Pricing is getting more public. Dover now posts an average cost per hire from 1,455 real hires, and Recruiting from Scratch posts its average days to hire. The classic model is still a contingency fee of 20 to 25% of first-year salary, as Dover's guide puts it. On a $180,000 engineer, that's $36,000 to $45,000 for one hire, against Dover's $4.8k average.

New York law also shapes every job ad an agency writes for you. Since November 1, 2022, the NYC Commission on Human Rights requires a good faith pay range in any ad for a job performed in New York City. The City Council notes it covers employers with four or more employees, so nearly every startup past the founders.

Our take: the ranking pages sort agencies by size or by who wrote the list. Sort by role type first and fee model second. A firm that's great at account executives is the wrong call for your first staff engineer.

From Clera's data: New York is dense with open roles

Clera's homepage lists 2,400+ startups and 1,400+ roles in New York, against 5,700+ startups and 1,700+ roles in the SF Bay Area. New York has well under half the Bay Area's startups on Clera, but more than 80% of its open roles. That's about one open role for every 1.7 New York startups, so speed and a warm first message matter here.

How to choose

  • If you're hiring engineers and want local specialists, start with Averity or Recruiting from Scratch.
  • If you're building a sales team, use Betts Recruiting.
  • If you're hiring your first VP of Engineering or CTO, pay for retained search at Riviera Partners.
  • If cash is tight and you're hiring several roles, compare Dover's hourly recruiters with Clera's pay-when-you-hire model before signing any 25% contract.

For firms outside New York, see our lists of the best recruiting agencies for startups and the best tech recruiters in San Francisco. If you're not sure you need an agency at all, our guide to the best alternatives to recruiting agencies covers the other routes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Contingency agencies typically charge 20 to 25% of first-year salary, according to Dover's NYC guide, and you pay only when someone starts. Retained executive search runs closer to a third of first-year cash compensation, per the same guide, and you commit before the search starts. Hourly marketplaces like Dover report a $4.8k average cost per hire.

Use contingency for individual contributor roles you could also fill yourself, since you only pay on success. Use retained search for a senior leader like a VP of Engineering, where you need a recruiter working the role full time and calling people who aren't looking.

Yes. Since November 1, 2022, any ad for a job performed in New York City must include a good faith pay range, according to the NYC Commission on Human Rights. Agree on the range with your agency before the first post goes up.

Recruiting from Scratch reports 29 days on average from kickoff to signed offer. Most firms don't publish a number, so ask for the median on their last ten placements for roles like yours.

Sources

Hire New York startup talent through Clera

Tell Clera who you're looking for, bid on candidates who already want a startup role, and get a warm intro to each one. You pay only when you hire. Hire through Clera.

Hiring? Let Clera source and screen your next hire

See how Clera compares to recruiting agencies